Dr. Scott Monteith: On a New Wonder "Drug" on the Market

I've posted several guest posts by Dr. Scott Monteith, a psychiatrist/informaticist, at Healthcare Renewal.

These include the Mar. 2011 post "On 'The Best Compromise' on Physicians and Use of Troublesome Health IT", the Jan. 2011 post "Interesting HIT Testimony to HHS Standards Committee, Jan. 11, 2011, by Dr. Monteith" and the Dec. 2010 post "Meaningful Use and the Devil in the Details: A Reader's View".

Here's a new guest post from Dr. Monteith regarding a new "Wonder Drug" on the market:

New Drug on the market!

This new drug claims to be incredibly effective. It’s very expensive, but the sellers assure us that it’s worth it!

Using the drug is complicated, and the health care team will likely experience side effects including frustration, reduced efficiency, fatigue, lack of attention, confusion, and cognitive dissonance (as the drug often “appears” not to work -- but it really does work and we know because the manufacturers consistently tell us it does).

By the way, the sellers of this new drug say that side effects are the fault of the people who use the drug, not the drug itself.

The drug isn’t proven to work, but its investors view it as promising and tell us that this small detail can be ignored. Besides, it would be costly to prove that it’s effective (remember, it’s already a very expensive drug).

And there are case studies showing that it appears to work. Some people reportedly really like it (these people, in fact, often become drug salesmen). Never mind that there are also large numbers of case studies indicating that it’s ineffective and dangerous, and can even kill people.

[Of course, cases of success are scientifically robust and universally valid; cases of adverse events are merely anecdotal (link) - ed.]

Nor do we have clear best practices related to correct dosages and when to take it, but the drug’s producers tell us that more of the drug is generally better than less. Everyone will have to figure out these minor details on their own. It’s recommended that you hire experts to help you with this detail. No problem – there are experts around every corner (they’re called “consultants”).

Please join the manufacturers in their campaign to use and promote this new drug – the government has! Uncle Sam will pay you an incentive to use this new experimental drug over the next few years. If you refuse to use it, however, beware! Uncle Sam will penalize caregivers who refuse to use the drug by reducing their payments by 1% in the first year, and then accelerating these reductions in years 2-5.

We also need to work hard to keep groups of citizens from regulating it, or asking inconvenient questions like “can you please prove that it works before we take it and risk side effects and spend large amounts of money on it?” (You know, the same kind of nasty questions that we ask of other health care interventions.)

Almost forgot…once you start the drug, it’s very hard to quit to using it. No, it’s not heroin. Don’t be silly!

Finally, we’re working hard to keep the manufacturers safe from any liability associated with the drug. Yes, yes, I know – they claim it’s safe and works and all problems are related to the people who take it. But these “safe harbors” (whether through government intervention or strong user agreements) are necessary ... just in case ...

By now I’m sure that you want to run out to your pharmacy to buy this wonderful new drug. You may also want to invest in its maker as well. So here are the details…

The generic name is “HIT.” The trade name is “EHR.” It’s stock symbol is ONC.

I think the point is very well made.

-- SS